To What End?

By Assemblyman Scott Gray, 116th District

New York is pushing large solar projects into rural communities that have said, clearly and repeatedly, that they do not want them. Through the Office of Renewable Energy Siting, the state can set aside a town's own zoning and local laws to make it happen. Before we cover another few hundred acres of farmland over a town's objection, it is fair to ask a simple question. To what end?

Start with the problem we actually have. The state's grid operator says New York entered this summer with a reliability margin of just 417 megawatts, down from more than 1,900 megawatts in 2022. It projects a shortfall of as much as 10,000 megawatts by 2034. What closes that gap? Firm baseload power: generation that runs day and night, in every season, whether or not the sun is out.

Solar cannot do that. In New York, a solar field produces power about 15% of the time, depending on the facility. Matching the yearly output of a single 1,100-megawatt nuclear reactor would take roughly 6,700 megawatts of solar and 52 to 105 square miles of land. On a January evening in the North Country, when demand peaks, solar output is close to zero. Every megawatt of solar still needs something else standing behind it—battery backup systems, synchronous condensers for grid firming, and ratepayers pay for all of it.

The same is true for the economy and jobs. Manufacturers and large employers in every community need available power around the clock. A factory floor cannot schedule its shifts around cloud cover. When a company asks what kind of power New York can promise, solar is not the answer it is looking for.

So, we have a policy that overrides local voices to build a resource that does not fix the supply shortage, does not power new industry and adds to utility bills along the way. If it doesn't solve the problem, why are we forcing it on communities that don't want it?

I am not against solar. Rooftop systems, panels on farms and businesses that offset their own bills and projects a community chooses to host all have value. If a town wants a solar project and negotiates a fair deal, I will stand with them. But addressing our supply deficit isn't in solar's portfolio, and neither is powering the next generation of manufacturing.

The state already has a better model on the table: advanced nuclear. New York's position is to allow willing communities to be hosts. That same standard should apply to solar. Let towns decide. Then let the state put its focus, and our money, into the firm power that will keep the lights on and bring jobs back upstate.

Rural New York is being asked to give up its land and its voice for a resource that cannot do the job that is required to fix our energy system. That is a poor trade, and every community deserves the right to say yes or no.